Filing Deadlines and the Useful-Safe-Life Rule: What These Mean for Your Claim
Section 6-1403 sets two time rules for product claims. First, "No claim under this chapter may be brought more than two (2) years from the time the cause of action accrued as defined in section 5-219, Idaho Code." That ties the product claim to the accrual rule above.
Second, the section uses "useful safe life," which "begins at the time of delivery of the product and extends for the time during which the product would normally be likely to perform or be stored in a safe manner." Delivery means delivery to the first buyer or lessee who was not in the business of selling the product or using it as a part in another product. In practice, that is usually the first ordinary customer, not a store or a company that built it into another device. Except as the section otherwise provides, a seller is not liable if it proves by a preponderance of the evidence that the harm was caused after the useful safe life had expired.
A statute of repose is a time limit measured from delivery, not from the injury. When harm is caused more than ten years after delivery, "a presumption arises that the harm was caused after the useful safe life had expired." That presumption "may only be rebutted by clear and convincing evidence." For an older battery, this can make a claim much harder to bring.
The ten-year period does not apply to harm caused by prolonged exposure to a defective product, an injury-causing aspect present at delivery that an ordinary reasonably prudent person could not discover until more than ten years after delivery, or harm caused within ten years that did not show itself until after that time. If one business is found liable, the section still lets it seek contribution or indemnity from others responsible, so who else shares responsibility can remain part of the case.
Children's claims follow a separate tolling rule in section 5-230, covered below. If the purchase date, the delivery date or the date of the fire is unclear, a case evaluation with our attorney can help put those dates in order.