Who May Be Responsible: What Product Liability Law Asks
Product liability claims are usually framed under one or both of two legal theories, and the details vary by state.
Under negligence, the claim rests on four questions about the company behind the product: whether it owed a duty of care to people who would use the product; whether it breached that duty, for example by designing, making or labeling the product carelessly; whether that breach caused the injury; and whether the injured person suffered damages.
Strict liability, recognized in many states for defective products, takes the focus off carelessness. It generally asks whether the product was defective when it left the company's hands, whether the defect caused the injury, and whether the person suffered damages. For a reader who has no way to know how carefully a battery was made, this theory centers on the product itself rather than the company's conduct. Whether these elements are met depends on the facts, the defect type and the state's law. A fire is not, by itself, proof of a defect.
Responsibility can reach more than one business. Depending on the state's law and the facts, manufacturers of the cell or the finished product, importers, distributors and retailers may each be part of the question. That is one reason the brand on the device, where it was bought and who sold it can matter. Our lithium battery injury lawyer page explains how the supply chain fits together.
Federal safety law runs alongside these claims but answers a different question. In the Consumer Product Safety Act, beginning at 15 U.S.C. § 2051, Congress found that "the public should be protected against unreasonable risks of injury associated with consumer products." Under 15 U.S.C. § 2064, after an opportunity for a hearing, the CPSC may order a manufacturer, distributor or retailer to give public notice of a product that presents a substantial product hazard and to repair, replace or refund it. That law governs safety and recalls; it does not decide whether a company owes anything to an injured person.
A statute of limitations is the deadline by which a lawsuit must be filed. These deadlines differ from state to state, as do the rules for when the clock starts running, and missing one can bar a claim entirely. A wrongful death claim is a claim brought by surviving family members when a person dies as a result of another's wrongful act; who may bring it, and on what terms, also differs by state.
People in this position often weigh which state's law applies, which businesses were in the product's chain, and which theory fits what the evidence shows. A conversation with an attorney can help sort through those questions against the applicable state's rules.